Year A: Proper 28 | Matthew 25:14-30
St. Andrew’s Episcopal Church
November 15, 2026
the Rev. Jonathan Hanneman
To watch the full service, please visit this page.
Although it looks straightforward enough, I find that many people approach this morning’s parable from a fear-based viewpoint or read it through a lens of top-down power dynamics, leading us to deeply misunderstand what Jesus is actually saying. Applying ideas from modern economic theories and practices, we often interpret this as reinforcing the view that God somehow blesses rich people while poverty is always the result of one’s own flaws or laziness. Translators’ blunt application of English adjectives, like “good,” “wicked,” and “worthless,”[1] certainly doesn’t help. Our tendency to trust the witness of the unreliable slave makes things even worse, leading us to imagine God as a cruel taskmaster. But this isn’t a tale of resentment or punishment—quite the opposite. The centuries of cultural drift just make it impossible to hear clearly. So here’s how the story might have sounded had Jesus been in a more modern context:
*****
Once upon a time, there was a family that owned a successful business. Known for being generous to their workers, everyone considered it a privilege to be employed there. Among their staff, the owners noticed three people in particular who had potential for advancement. As they prepared to head overseas to negotiate some complicated contracts, the owners decided to give these three employees the opportunity to prove themselves. Recognizing each one’s different capabilities and time spent with the company, the owners chose to present them with different types of projects while providing all the funds necessary to accomplish the tasks. For the one they’d been watching longest, they assigned five projects, each with a budget of $50,000.[2] The second they assigned two projects, each with the same budget as the first one’s. For the newest of the employees, they assigned a single project, also allowing access to $50,000—substantially more than would be required to complete it.
The trip took some time—more than enough for the employees to work through their assignments successfully. Upon returning, the owners called each one in to see what they had achieved. The first worker reported that, in the course of completing their five projects, they recognized another five that would make the original ones even more successful. During the absence, they had completed all ten projects, not only enhancing the company’s reputation but already doubling the owners’ $250,000 investment, with only more profits to come. The owners were thrilled to see their employee flourishing and promoted them to an upper management position where they would be in charge of five divisions of the company, have their lunches covered in the executive dining room, and be eligible for a nice bonus at the end of the year.
When the second employee came in, it turned out that they, too, had successfully completed all their projects plus two extra, also doubling the owners’ investment in the relatively short period of time. Thrilled again with how well their employee had done, they promoted this go-getter as well, giving them a new position commensurate with what they had accomplished, a job that also included free lunch and the opportunity for a substantial bonus.
As the third employee approached, the owners could sense something was off. The person appeared reluctant and embarrassed—possibly even sullen. Recognizing that things obviously hadn’t gone great, they were still eager to hear what the staff member had managed to accomplish. Standing before them, the worker muttered, “I know how harsh you guys are—you don’t stand for failure, and you’re dismissive of incompetent staff. Since I didn’t want to disappoint you, I decided the best course of action was to just not touch the assignment at all. Here’s your $50,000 back.”
After the success they had just encountered, the owners were stunned. Pausing for a confused moment, they said, “Wait—you thought we’re ‘harsh,’ that we won’t ‘stand for failure,’ and that we’re ‘dismissive of incompetent staff’? Yet at the same time, you ‘didn’t want to disappoint us’? If that’s true, then why in the world would you not even try? That makes no sense. I guess we’ll have to move the position we were hoping to offer you under the first employee instead. We don’t want to fire you, but your sense of initiative is disappointing, and you obviously aren’t the management material we hoped you could be. You can stay with the company, but since we already filled your old position when we were expecting to promote you, we’ll have to move you out to the front gate.”
The employee was deeply ashamed but, still grateful to be working for such a generous organization, accepted the demotion. From then on, however, whenever they felt the summer heat beating through the glass or a winter chill sneaked into the booth alongside them, every time they unwrapped their homemade peanut butter and jelly sandwich for lunch, they berated themself, ruing the foolishness that had brought them there.
*****
Jesus’ parable isn’t a tale of harshness and greed. Nor is it a tale of unduly rewarding the wealthy while cruelty depriving the poor of what little they do have. This is a tale of generosity, of a kind boss hoping to give their employees a chance at advancement. Two of the employees rise to the challenge brilliantly. One, while watching the others make progress on their assignments, chooses to not even try—and then excuses their own lack of effort by badmouthing the boss to their face. Despite our assumptions, the “outer darkness”—in this or any other parable—isn’t a metaphor for Hell or damnation. The boss or king or whomever doesn’t throw the person away and leave them to rot in starvation or misery. They remain part of the household. But whereas they had previously been working inside the house where it was warm and they could grab a snack whenever they needed to, now they’re stuck outside, bored with their labor and subject to the elements. The weeping and teeth grinding aren’t signs of pain but expressions of regret over their own choices that led to the current situation.
I would argue that our negative interpretation of Jesus’ parable rises from our own deeply embedded misexpectations of God. As we’ve talked about before, God is not a Sky Emperor. God doesn’t function as the Zeus-like figure we constantly imagine—someone watching our every move, knowing (or even dictating) our every thought, and ready to smite us at a moment’s notice. That’s a god built in humanity’s image—a god intent on using power, control, and every available advantage to maintain their own authority, keep others down, and make themself more comfortable and secure. Who knows whether a god like that actually exists, but even if it does, it’s the antithesis of the God who repeatedly freed the Hebrew people and the one Jesus modeled and displayed throughout the course of his life.
God is not a tyrant. The nature of God—the true God, the all-caps LORD—is to be the Provider—the Source and Fountain behind and empowering all that is. God presents us with life and energy and, similarly to the business owner, opportunity. And like the business owner, God gives us those opportunities in the expectation that we could take advantage of them—not for selfish gain but so we might be able to recognize and enjoy our own growth as children of God’s Kingdom.
Unlike where the story ended, despite our failures, God continues to give us opportunities. The business owners weren’t looking for reasons to demote anyone. Based on how Jesus presents the “master” throughout the course of the story, even if the third employee had lost money in the course of his assignment, I’m pretty sure no one would have been sent to the gate house. They wanted the employees to succeed. The owners were actively looking for reasons to reward their workers. The third employee didn’t lose out because they didn’t have the skills to accomplish their task; their failure came from refusing to even try.
So then, how about you? Where might God be giving you opportunities to prove yourself? In what areas can you sense the Source and Provider of Life urging you forward as they eagerly wait to celebrate your efforts?
Maybe you’re thinking, “I’ve already missed my opportunities; there’s nothing left for me but regret.” I would challenge that way of thinking. God remains as generous as ever. What I think happens is that as we pass up the chances God keeps giving, we lose the ability to recognize them for what they are. If that’s the case, we simply need to begin looking for the small ways to move forward; as we start to exercise our abilities and agency again, we’ll begin to notice larger opportunities to prove ourselves.
This parable isn’t meant to discourage us. It’s a challenge to reach for more, to pay attention to the openings God offers each and every day so we can grow within God’s Image and as citizens of God’s reign. Success itself—doubling profits, exceeding expectations, and earning promotions—is not the point. The important thing is that God continues to be generous, offering us opportunity after opportunity to succeed. All God truly asks is that we try.
[1] Better choices would be along the lines of “capable,” “incompetent,” and “inept.” Similarly, in last week’s parable, “wise” and “foolish” would be better presented along the lines of “sensible” and “apathetic.”
[2] Roughly the current value of the “talent” (an ancient measurement of weight applied to precious metals) mentioned throughout the text. Note that, as the measurement differed across cultures and eras, exact equivalency is impossible to determine. This estimate is based on the silver Hebrew talent, which was close to 75 pounds.
